標題
Title
從理性選擇理論評澳門第七屆立法會直選結果
Comments on the Results of Macao’s 2021 Legislative Assembly Election from the Perspective of Rational Choice Theory
作者
Author
史超宇,陳建新
SHI Chaoyu, CHAN Kin Sun
摘要
Abstract
澳門特區有序地完成了第七屆澳門立法會直接選舉,低投票率和白票廢票數量增加都引來了社會關注,加上選前有五組非建制派候選人被取消資格,新一屆澳門立法會的代表性和監察力也受到社會的一定質疑。本研究主要使用理性選擇理論模型去分析此次選舉結果:首先解釋了本屆立法會直選投票率較低是受到選民預期成本和期待效應的影響, 並且聯繫香港區議會選舉來對比分析,對高投票率選舉的意義進行了一定的反思;接着發現白票和廢票沒有存在突出數量問題,將選民投白票和廢票歸因鐘擺效應,從而發現白票和廢票或受到鄰近地區謠言所影響;最後通過回顧第六屆澳門立法會議員的質詢紀錄和《澳門基本法》的規定,回應了對本屆澳門立法會選舉結果的代表性和監察力的質疑。整體上, 本研究發現第七屆澳門立法會選舉體現了選舉的公平和選民意向的集中。

The Macao SAR has just completed the election of the 7th Legislative Assembly 2021 in an orderly manner, but both the low turnout rate and the increasing number of blank and invalid votes drew the public’s attention. In addition, five groups of non-establishment candidates were disqualified just before the election, so that the representativeness and supervisory power of the newly formed Macao Legislative Assembly have also been doubted by the public. This study mainly adopts the rational choice theory to analyse the results of the direct election. First, the low turnout rate in the direct elections is affected by the expected costs (the risk and inconvenience triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic) and expected benefits (the reduced choice of candidates and the public satisfaction on the Government’s performance on COVID-19 prevention) of eligible voters. According to the results of the Hong Kong District Council Election 2019, the high turnout rates may not lead to better governance. The high proportion of blank votes and invalid votes may be caused by the pendulum effects, or the high proportion is triggered by some “manipulated” issues, like rumors and fake news. By comparing the performance in the number of enquiries by directly elected members of the 6th Legislative Assembly, there is no significant difference between DQ and pro-establishment directly elected members. All in all, this study concludes that the results of the 7th Macao Legislative Assembly Election, which can be verified by Rational Choice Theory, argues the election was a fair and representative one.

關鍵詞
Keywords
澳門立法會選舉,香港區議會選舉,投票率,理性選擇理論
Macao Legislative Assembly election, Hong Kong District Council election, Turnout rates, Rational choice theory
下載
Download
Links